Suggestions by @milesyeargain

Sigourney Weaver

as Queen Hippolyta in Wonder Woman: Lady of Justice (1996)

Brad Pitt

as Steve Trevor in Wonder Woman: Lady of Justice (1996)

Clancy Brown

as Ares in Wonder Woman: Lady of Justice (1996)

Famke Janssen (Wonder Woman)

as Wonder Woman in Wonder Woman: Lady of Justice (1996)

Marisa Tomei

as Mary Jane Watson-Parker in The Amazing Spider-Man 3 (1992)

FAKE

as Cyclops in X-Men (1992)

Kevin Costner

as Aquaman in Aquaman: King of The Seven Seas (1995)

Wesley Snipes

as Ma’alefa’ak in Justice League (1996)

Djimon Hounsou

as Black Manta in Justice League (1996)

Lance Henriksen

as Sinestro in Justice League (1996)

Mel Gibson

as Captain Cold in Justice League (1996)

Meryl Streep

as Cheetah in Justice League (1996)

Brad Dourif

as Scarecrow in Justice League (1996)

Jack Nicholson (Lex Luthor)

as Lex Luthor in Justice League (1996)

Laurence Fishburne (Martian Manhunter)

as Martian Manhunter in Justice League (1996)

Val Kilmer

as Aquaman in Justice League (1996)

FAKE

as Green Lantern in Justice League (1996)

Luke Perry

as The Flash in Justice League (1996)

Famke Janssen (Wonder Woman)

as Wonder Woman in Justice League (1996)

Alec Baldwin

as Batman in Justice League (1996)