Suggestions by @milesyeargain

Superman (Christopher Reeve)

as Superman in Justice League Live Action 1977-1983

FAKE

as Batman in Justice League Live Action 1977-1983

Burt Reynolds

as Sheriff Beauford T. Justice in Smokey and The Bandit (1997) Remake

Sean Connery

as Magneto in X-men Origins: Cyclops and Jean Grey (2000)

Julia Roberts

as Mystique in X-men Origins: Cyclops and Jean Grey (2000)

Natalie Portman

as Jean Grey in X-men Origins: Cyclops and Jean Grey (2000)

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Cyclops in X-men Origins: Cyclops and Jean Grey (2000)

Patrick Stewart

as Professor X in X-Men Origins: Wolverine (1999)

Patrick Stewart

as Professor X in X-men Origins: Nightcrawler (2000)

Winona Ryder

as Scarlet Witch in X-men Origins: Nightcrawler (2000)

Dolph Lundgren

as Avalanche in X-men Origins: Nightcrawler (2000)

Alan Cummings

as Nightcrawler in X-men Origins: Nightcrawler (2000)

Patrick Stewart

as Professor X in X-Men Origins: Storm (2000)

Blair Underwood

as Black Panther in X-Men Origins: Storm (2000)

Keith David

as The Shadow King in X-Men Origins: Storm (2000)

Halle Berry

as Storm in X-Men Origins: Storm (2000)

Johnny Depp (young)

as Maverick in X-Men Origins: Wolverine (1999)

Brad Garrett

as Blob in X-Men Origins: Wolverine (1999)

FAKE

as Kayla Silverfox in X-Men Origins: Wolverine (1999)

Jet Li

as Agent Zero in X-Men Origins: Wolverine (1999)