Suggestions by @mike1seravello

Valerie Malone

as Alicia Silverstone in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Cici Cooper

as Alicia Silverstone in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Maureen Evans

as Rebecca Gayheart in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Cici Cooper

as Rebecca Gayheart in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Nancy Drew (2007)

as Freddie Prinze Jr. in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

TOM (Toonami)

as Freddie Prinze Jr. in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Billy Loomis

as Freddie Prinze Jr. in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Billy Loomis

as Vince Vaughn in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Billy Loomis

as Joaquin Phoenix in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Billy Loomis

as Ben Affleck in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Jerry Maguire

as Janeane Garofalo in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Usagi Tsukino

as Melissa Joan Hart in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

I Know What You Did Last Summer

as Melissa Joan Hart in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Blossom (TV Show)

as Melissa Joan Hart in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Punky Brewster

as Melissa Joan Hart in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Sidney Prescott

as Alicia Witt in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Jerry Maguire

as Molly Ringwald in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

A League of Their Own

as Molly Ringwald in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Kim Boggs

as Molly Ringwald in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted

Ghost (film)

as Molly Ringwald in Roles That Actors / Actresses Were ALMOST Casted