Suggestions by @midnightpappii
19 suggestions
Jake Brennan
as James Finch in American Pie 5
Dania Ramirez
as Selena in American Pie 5
Thomas Brodie-Sangster
as Stanley Stifler in American Pie 5
Asa Butterfield
as Jason Levenstein in American Pie 5
Cole Sprouse
as Jason Levenstein in American Pie 5
Darren Barnet
as Samuel Myers in American Pie 5
Dylan O'Brien
as Thomas Ostreicher in American Pie 5
Thomas Ian Nicholas
as Kevin Myers in American Pie 5
Natasha Lyonne
as Jessica in American Pie 5
Jason Biggs
as Jim Levenstein in American Pie 5
Mena Suvari
as Heather in American Pie 5
John Cho
as John in American Pie 5
Alyson Hannigan
as Michelle Flaherty in American Pie 5
Tara Reid
as Victoria "Vicky" in American Pie 5
Chris Klein
as Chris "Oz" Ostreicher in American Pie 5
Justin Isfeld
as Justin in American Pie 5
Eddie Kaye Thomas
as Paul Finch in American Pie 5
Chris Owen
as Chuck Sherman in American Pie 5
Seann William Scott
as Steve Stifler in American Pie 5