Suggestions by @micahmadera

Mark Williams

as Bilbo Baggins in The Hobbit Trilogy Ten Years Earlier

Robin Williams

as Bilbo Baggins in The Hobbit Trilogy Ten Years Earlier

Tom Hollander

as Bilbo Baggins in The Hobbit Trilogy Ten Years Earlier

Val Kilmer

as ryland grace in Project Hail Mary (1996)

Jensen Ackles

as Hal Jordan in CW Green Lantern

Nicolas Cage

as 2000s in What Actors Could've Played Ryland Grace in various decades?

Ryan Reynolds

as 2020s in What Actors Could've Played Ryland Grace in various decades?

Chris Pratt

as 2020s in What Actors Could've Played Ryland Grace in various decades?

Chris Pine

as 2020s in What Actors Could've Played Ryland Grace in various decades?

Chris Evans

as 2020s in What Actors Could've Played Ryland Grace in various decades?

Jake Gyllenhaal

as 2020s in What Actors Could've Played Ryland Grace in various decades?

James Marsden

as 2010s in What Actors Could've Played Ryland Grace in various decades?

Matt Damon

as Ryland Grace in Project Hail Mary (2016)

Jason Segel

as 2020s in What Actors Could've Played Ryland Grace in various decades?

Harrison Ford

as 1980s in What Actors Could've Played Ryland Grace in various decades?

Val Kilmer

as 1990s in What Actors Could've Played Ryland Grace in various decades?

Brad Pitt

as 2000s in What Actors Could've Played Ryland Grace in various decades?

Hank Green

as 2010s in What Actors Could've Played Ryland Grace in various decades?

Matt Damon

as 2010s in What Actors Could've Played Ryland Grace in various decades?

Brendan Fraser

as 2000s in What Actors Could've Played Ryland Grace in various decades?