Suggestions by @miagothatexoxo

Jack Champion

as Mateo Foster in American Horror Story Wild West

Sarah Paulson

as Annie Foster in American Horror Story Wild West

Mia Goth

as Cassidy Mahan in American Horror Story Wild West

Madelyn Cline

as Matilda Stauk in American Horror Story Wild West

Louis Partridge

as Johnny Claiborne in American Horror Story Wild West

Jennifer Coolidge

as Diana Buntline in American Horror Story Wild West

Emma Roberts

as Rose Brady in American Horror Story Wild West

Cheyenne Jackson

as Frank in American Horror Story Amusement Park

Sarah Paulson

as Reese in American Horror Story Amusement Park

Emma Roberts

as Willow in American Horror Story Amusement Park

Samara Weaving

as Sasha in American Horror Story Amusement Park

Noah Centineo

as Ethan in American Horror Story Amusement Park

Finn Wittrock

as Josh in American Horror Story Amusement Park

Jenna Ortega

as Laura in American Horror Story Amusement Park

Denis O'Hare

as Eric in American Horror Story Amusement Park

Frances Conroy

as Fiona Lovell in American Horror Story Perfection

Madison Iseman

as Veronica Watson in American Horror Story Perfection

Louis Partridge

as Jack Walker in American Horror Story Perfection

Hailee Steinfeld

as Mia Wade in American Horror Story Perfection

Noah Centineo

as Brayden Walters in American Horror Story Perfection