Suggestions by @miagothatexoxo
12,263 suggestions
Jessica Lange
as Returning actresses in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Kelsey Lea Jones
as Returning actresses in Actors and Actresses who should be in American Horror Story
Denis O'Hare
as Monty in American Horror Story Urban Legends
Billie Lourd
as Cassandra in American Horror Story Urban Legends
Frances Conroy
as Eve in American Horror Story Urban Legends
Sarah Michelle Gellar
as Yolanda in American Horror Story Urban Legends
Lily Rabe
as Samantha in American Horror Story Urban Legends
Jack Champion
as Archie in American Horror Story Urban Legends
James Spader
as Fernando in American Horror Story Urban Legends
Eva Green
as Laura in American Horror Story Urban Legends
Finn Wittrock
as Jerold in American Horror Story Urban Legends
Emma Roberts
as Gabby in American Horror Story Urban Legends
Sarah Paulson
as Albie in American Horror Story Urban Legends
Vera Farmiga
as Roslyn in American Horror Story Urban Legends
Salma Hayek
as Emery in American Horror Story Salem
Zachary Quinto
as Kevin Weir in American Horror Story Harbour
Evan Peters
as Timothy Marshall in American Horror Story Harbour
Sarah Paulson
as Lisa Gray in American Horror Story Harbour
Samuel L. Jackson
as Brian Nicol in American Horror Story Harbour
Anya Taylor-Joy
as Heather Gibson in American Horror Story Harbour