Suggestions by @miagothatexoxo

Sophie Thatcher

as Holly in The Idol Season 2

Finn Wittrock

as Johnny in The Idol Season 2

Christine Ko

as Jada in The Idol Season 2

Maitreyi Ramakrishnan

as Riley in The Idol Season 2

Cara Delevingne

as Kira in The Idol Season 2

Samara Weaving

as Mia in The Idol Season 2

Kate Lyn Sheil

as Amy in The Idol Season 2

Bianca Ghezzi

as Bianca in The Idol Season 2

Jeff Wolfe

as Tony in The Idol Season 2

charly summer

as Charly in The Idol Season 2

Alexa Demie

as Maddy Perez in The Idol Season 2

Melanie Liburd

as Jenna in The Idol Season 2

Eli Roth

as Andrew Finkelstein in The Idol Season 2

Dan Levy

as Benjamin in The Idol Season 2

Mitch Modes

as Mitch in The Idol Season 2

Sophie Mudd

as Sophie in The Idol Season 2

Hank Azaria

as Chaim in The Idol Season 2

ramsey

as Ramsey in The Idol Season 2

Da'Vine Joy Randolph

as Destiny in The Idol Season 2

Hari Nef

as Talia in The Idol Season 2