Suggestions by @miagothatexoxo

Avantika

as Daisy Smith in Christmassacre

Sasha Pieterse

as Lottie Crane in Christmassacre

Ella Purnell

as Emily Ploughman in Christmassacre

Tom Holland

as Jupiter Law in Christmassacre

Kristen Maxwell

as Grace Harper in Christmassacre

Madison Iseman

as Maya Macher in Christmassacre

Israel Broussard

as Samuel Pond in Christmassacre

Sydney Sweeney

as Mia Macher in Christmassacre

Rosamund Pike

as Professor Joslyn Parker in Christmassacre

Kathryn Newton

as Bambi Carson in Christmassacre

Margot Robbie

as Officer Alyson Strudel in Christmassacre

Reese Witherspoon

as Lillian Howard in Christmassacre

Lovie Simone

as Kylie Payne in Christmassacre

Maia Reficco

as Cassandra Diaz in Christmassacre

Aubrey Plaza

as Alba González in Christmassacre

Tanner Buchanan

as Matthew Rhodes in Christmassacre

Salma Hayek

as Lupita González in Christmassacre

Mia Goth

as Jasmine Myers in Christmassacre

Jenna Ortega

as Valeria González in Christmassacre

Annabeth Gish

as Dies in Pretty Little Liars: Scene Stealer