Suggestions by @melon

Evan Peters

as Alberto Falcone in Batman: Vigilante

Jude Law

as Jack Napier in Batman: Vigilante

Oscar Isaac

as Bane in Batman: Vigilante

Nicolas Cage

as Carmine Falcone in Batman: Vigilante

Matthew McConaughey

as James Gordon in Batman: Vigilante

Adam Sandler

as Oswald Cobblepot in Batman: Vigilante

Hugh Laurie

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman: Vigilante

James Spader

as Dr. Hugo Strange in Batman: Vigilante

Michael Fassbender

as Bruce Wayne in Batman: Vigilante

Brendan Fraser

as Harvey Bullock in Batman: Vigilante

Alexander Skarsgård

as Harvey Dent in Batman: Vigilante