Suggestions by @meganwhalen
700 suggestions
Jarrod Emick
as Shrek in Shrek The Musical
+0-4Score: -4
Roger Miller
as Shrek in Shrek The Musical
+0-4Score: -4
Patrick Wilson
as Shrek in Shrek The Musical
+4-3Score: +1
Michael Arden
as Shrek in Shrek The Musical
+2-6Score: -4
Aaron Tveit
as Sky in Mamma Mia!
+8-1Score: +7
Annaleigh Ashford
as Sophie in Mamma Mia!
+0-3Score: -3
Kerry Butler
as Sophie in Mamma Mia!
+0-3Score: -3
Laura Osnes
as Sophie in Mamma Mia!
+0-6Score: -6
Christy Altomare
as Sophie in Mamma Mia!
+11-2Score: +9
John Rubinstein
as Harry in Mamma Mia!
+1-0Score: +1
Tony Sheldon
as Bill in Mamma Mia!
+2-0Score: +2
Michael Damian
as Bill in Mamma Mia!
+0-1Score: -1
Stark Sands
as Bill in Mamma Mia!
+1-1Score: 0
Norbert Leo Butz
as Sam in Mamma Mia!
+1-0Score: +1
Aaron Tveit
as Sam in Mamma Mia!
+0-1Score: -1
Robert Klein
as Sam in Mamma Mia!
+0-1Score: -1
Donny Osmond
as Sam in Mamma Mia!
+5-0Score: +5
Jodie Prenger
as Tanya in Mamma Mia!
+0-0Score: 0
Elaine Paige
as Tanya in Mamma Mia!
+0-0Score: 0
Linda Eder
as Tanya in Mamma Mia!
+1-0Score: +1