Suggestions by @maxthecat67

Theda Bara

as Nightmare Chica in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

George Bancroft

as Nightmare Bonnie in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

Elmo Lincoln

as Nightmare Freddy in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

John Barrymore

as Spring Bonnie in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

W.C. Fields

as Fredbear in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

Bette Davis

as Phantom Puppet in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

Dickie Jones

as Phantom Balloon Boy in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

Mae West

as Phantom Mangle in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

Conrad Veidt

as Phantom Foxy in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

Marion Davies

as Phantom Chica in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

Roscoe Arbuckle

as Phantom Freddy in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

Bela Lugosi

as William Afton in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

Ernest Thesiger

as Shadow Bonnie in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

Sydney Greenstreet

as Shadow Freddy in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

Bette Davis

as Puppet in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

Shirley Temple

as JJ in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

Dickie Jones

as Balloon Boy in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

Paul Robeson

as Withered Golden Freddy in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

Conrad Veidt

as Withered Foxy in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)

Marion Davies

as Withered Chica in Five Nights At Freddy's (1934-1937)