Suggestions by @maxcarter
3,103 suggestions

Verosika Mayday
as Lucille Ball in Characters golden age stars could have played

Lady (Thomas The Tank Engine)
as Judy Garland in Characters golden age stars could have played

Black Hot (Villainous)
as Paul Robeson in Characters golden age stars could have played

Andrealphus (Helluva Boss)
as John Barrymore in Characters golden age stars could have played

Erich von Stroheim
as Hymeks in The Little Engine That Could 2 Return of the Railroad (1945)

Rosie (Thomas and Friends)
as Katharine Hepburn in Characters golden age stars could have played

Spawn (Albert Simmons)
as Paul Robeson in Characters golden age stars could have played

Candyman (Daniel Robitaille)
as Paul Robeson in Characters golden age stars could have played

Emily (Thomas & Friends)
as Elsa Lanchester in Characters golden age stars could have played

V (Murder Drones)
as Katharine Hepburn in Characters golden age stars could have played

Uzi Doorman
as Lucille Ball in Characters golden age stars could have played

Wheatley (Portal)
as Claude Rains in Characters golden age stars could have played

Sniper
as Cary Grant in Characters golden age stars could have played

Demoman
as Paul Robeson in Characters golden age stars could have played

Engineer
as John Wayne in Characters golden age stars could have played

Pinto Colvig
as Eric's dog in The Little Engine That Could 2 Return of the Railroad (1945)

Bela Lugosi
as Ghost Train in What if Warner Bros Owned The Little Engine That Could
John Barrymore
as Montana in The Little Engine That Could 2 Return of the Railroad (1945)
Lana Turner
as Elsa the Snow Queen in Classic Hero Actors as Modern Heros
Judy Garland
as Queen Anna of Arendelle in Classic Hero Actors as Modern Heros