Suggestions by @matthewweikert
3,298 suggestions
Fran Brill
as Prairie Dawn in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Jerry Nelson
as Herry Monster in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Leslie Carrara-Rudolph
as Abby Cadabby in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Frank Oz
as Grover in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Carmen Osbahr
as Rosita (Sesame Street) in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Caroll Spinney
as Oscar the Grouch in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Steve Whitmire
as Ernie in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Jerry Nelson
as Count Von Count in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Fran Brill
as Zoe in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Martin P. Robinson
as Telly in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Kevin Clash
as Elmo in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Bono
as Clay Calloway in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Halsey
as Porsha Crystal in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Scarlett Johansson
as Ash (Sing) in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Tori Kelly
as Meena (Sing) in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Letitia Wright
as Nooshy (Sing) in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Reese Witherspoon
as Rosita (Sing) in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Nick Kroll
as Gunter (Sing) in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Adam Buxton
as Klaus Kickenklober in Be My Valentine, Matthew
Eric André
as Darius (Sing) in Be My Valentine, Matthew