Suggestions by @matthewweikert

LaShawn Jefferies

as Uniqua in Matthew's Easter Party

Susanne Blakeslee

as Lady Tremaine in Matthew's Easter Party

Jodi Benson

as Ariel in Matthew's Easter Party

Naelee Rae

as Tasha in Matthew's Easter Party

Harvey Fierstein

as Easter Bunny in Matthew's Easter Party

Martin P. Robinson

as Telly in Matthew's Easter Party

Slimey

as Slimey the Worm in Matthew's Easter Party

Caroll Spinney

as Oscar the Grouch in Matthew's Easter Party

Tress MacNeille

as Daisy Duck in Matthew's Easter Party

Jerry Nelson

as Count Von Count in Matthew's Easter Party

Jerry Nelson

as Lew Zealand in Matthew's Easter Party

Jeff Conaway

as Kenickie in Matthew's Easter Party

Olivia Newton-John

as Sandy Olsson in Matthew's Easter Party

Matthew Weikert

as Matthew Weikert in Matthew's Easter Party

Vanessa Hudgens

as Rizzo in Matthew's Easter Party

John Travolta

as Danny Zuko in Matthew's Easter Party

Leslie Carrara-Rudolph

as Abby Cadabby in Matthew's Easter Party

Kevin Clash

as Elmo in Matthew's Easter Party

Pablo (The Backyardigans)

as Little Boy in Be My Valentine, Matthew

Kenickie

as Calloway's Conscience in Be My Valentine, Matthew