Suggestions by @matthewweikert
3,298 suggestions
Frank Welker
as Fred Jones in Matthew's Halloween Party
Pam Arciero
as Grundgetta in Matthew's Halloween Party
Caroll Spinney
as Oscar the Grouch in Matthew's Halloween Party
Tyler Bunch
as Treelo in Matthew's Halloween Party
Noel MacNeal
as Bear in Matthew's Halloween Party
Peter Linz
as Tutter in Matthew's Halloween Party
Matt Frewer
as Panic in Matthew's Halloween Party
Bobcat Goldthwait
as Pain in Matthew's Halloween Party
Susan Egan
as Megara in Matthew's Halloween Party
James Woods
as Hades in Matthew's Halloween Party
Kevin Clash
as Mulch in Matthew's Halloween Party
Brian Henson
as Dr. Phil van Neuter in Matthew's Halloween Party
David Rudman
as Two-Headed Monster (2) in Matthew's Halloween Party
Jerry Nelson
as Two-Headed Monster in Matthew's Halloween Party
James Patrick Stuart
as Emperor Zurg in Matthew's Halloween Party
Andrew Stanton
as Emperor Zurg in Matthew's Halloween Party
Tyler Bunch
as Pop in Matthew's Halloween Party
Peter Linz
as Pip in Matthew's Halloween Party
Vicki Eibner
as Ojo in Matthew's Halloween Party
Craig Robinson
as Phineas P. Pock in Matthew's Halloween Party