Suggestions by @matthewweikert
3,298 suggestions
Frank Oz
as Bert in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Frank Oz
as Cookie Monster in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Thomas Sharkey
as Austin (singing) in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Jonah Bobo
as Austin in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Kristin Klabunde
as Tasha (singing) in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
James Caan
as Father Time in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Naelee Rae
as Tasha in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Sean Curley
as Pablo (singing) in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Zach Tyler Eisen
as Pablo in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Mr. Lawrence
as Sheldon J. Plankton in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Fran Brill
as Zoe in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Kevin Clash
as Elmo in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Vanessa Hudgens
as Rizzo in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Matthew Weikert
as Matthew Weikert in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Jeff Conaway
as Kenickie in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Scarlett Johansson
as Jovie in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Kelly Ward
as Putzie in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Jamie Donnelly
as Jan in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Didi Conn
as Frenchy in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party
Barry Pearl
as Doody in Matthew's New Year's Eve Party