Suggestions by @ matthewhedrichjr

Lily James

as Martha Jefferson in 1776

+2-1Score: +1

Justin Theroux

as John Hancock (MA), Congressional President in 1776

Dan Stevens

as Alexander Hamilton in 1776

Justin Theroux

as John Hancock in 1776

Jack Davenport

as Lord Wolfgang in Odette

+2-1Score: +1

Jack Davenport

as Lord Rogers in The Swan Princess: Escape from Castle Mountain

Jack Davenport

as Lord Rogers in The Swan Princess

George Bruns

as Composer in Aladdin (1960s)

+7-0Score: +7

Stephen Dillane

as Hans Conried in Who Should Play Dead Celebrties

Paul Giamatti

as Vernon Dent in The Three Stooges (2022)

Scarlett Johansson

as Plumette in Beauty and the Beast (2012)

Paul Giamatti

as Cogsworth in Beauty and the Beast (2012)

+2-1Score: +1

Stephen Dillane

as Lumiere in Beauty and the Beast (2012)

Stanley Tucci

as Cadenza in Beauty and the Beast and The Enchanted Christmas

+3-0Score: +3

Justin Theroux

as John Hancock in The Revolution

Gugu Mbatha-Raw

as Sally Hemings in The Revolution

+3-0Score: +3

David Morse

as George Washington in The Revolution

Dan Stevens

as Alexander Hamilton in The Revolution

Ewan McGregor

as Thomas Jefferson in The Revolution