Suggestions by @masterofcool

Josh Hutcherson

as Peter Shepherd in Jumanji (2005)

Paul McGann

as Samuel Parrish in Jumanji (2005)

Paul McGann

as Van Pelt in Jumanji (2005)

Kristen Wiig

as 22 in Soul (2020)

Don Cheadle

as Joe Gardner in Soul (2020)

Alfred Molina

as Count Tyrone Rugen in The Princess Bride (1997)

Nathan Lane

as The Albino in The Princess Bride (1997)

Joan Cusack

as Valerie in The Princess Bride (1997)

Eric Idle

as The Impressive Clergyman in The Princess Bride (1997)

Steve Carell

as Miracle Max in The Princess Bride (1997)

Antonio Banderas

as Inigo Montoya in The Princess Bride (1997)

Kate Winslet

as Buttercup in The Princess Bride (1997)

Brendan Fraser

as Westley in The Princess Bride (1997)

Robert Pattinson

as The Joker in Tom Mankiewicz's The Batman

Vincent D'Onofrio

as Rupert Thorne in Tom Mankiewicz's The Batman

Tilda Swinton

as Gutless in Hook (2001)

Kirsten Dunst

as Wendy Darling in Hook (2001)

Julie Andrews

as Granny Wendy in Hook (2001)

Anton Yelchin

as Jack Banning in Hook (2001)

Dakota Fanning

as Maggie Banning in Hook (2001)