Suggestions by @masterofcool

Telly Savalas

as Jack Crawford in Manhunter (1976)

Oliver Reed

as Francis Dollarhyde in Manhunter (1976)

Al Pacino

as Will Graham in Manhunter (1976)

Rebecca Ferguson

as Evil-Lyn in Masters of the Universe (Dark Fantasy Reboot)

Henry Cavill

as He-Man in Masters of the Universe (Dark Fantasy Reboot)

Michael Jai White

as Tito Biondi in Face/Off (2007)

Liev Schreiber

as Dr. Malcolm Walsh in Face/Off (2007)

R. Lee Ermey

as Victor Lazzaro in Face/Off (2007)

Josh Brolin

as Dietrich Hassler in Face/Off (2007)

Kristen Stewart

as Jamie Archer in Face/Off (2007)

Penélope Cruz

as Sasha Hassler in Face/Off (2007)

Wes Bentley

as Pollux Troy in Face/Off (2007)

Laura Dern

as Eve Archer in Face/Off (2007)

Matthew McConaughey

as Castor Troy in Face/Off (2007)

Tom Cruise

as Sean Archer in Face/Off (2007)

Robert De Niro

as Andrew Laeddis in Shutter Island (1990)

Danny DeVito

as Deputy Warden McPherson in Shutter Island (1990)

Harvey Keitel

as Warden in Shutter Island (1990)

John Lithgow

as George Noyce in Shutter Island (1990)

Ann-Margret

as Dr. Rachel Solando in Shutter Island (1990)