Suggestions by @maryannkaragits

Jackie Gleason

as Jack Riley in Actors' Classic Counterparts

Tim Conway

as Rodger Bumpass in Actors' Classic Counterparts

Bill Cosby

as Rodger Bumpass in Actors' Classic Counterparts

Jonathan Winters

as Rodger Bumpass in Actors' Classic Counterparts

Mel Blanc

as Rodger Bumpass in Actors' Classic Counterparts

Thurl Ravenscroft

as Brad Garrett in Actors' Classic Counterparts

Rodney Dangerfield

as Brad Garrett in Actors' Classic Counterparts

Sammy Davis Jr.

as Brad Garrett in Actors' Classic Counterparts

Ken Sansom

as Brent Bumpass in Actors' Classic Counterparts

Bela Lugosi

as Nicolas Cage in Actors' Older Counterparts

Robert De Niro

as Nicolas Cage in Actors' Older Counterparts

James Dean

as Nicolas Cage in Actors' Older Counterparts

Bela Lugosi

as Nicolas Cage in Actors' Classic Counterparts

Claude Rains

as Jake Gyllenhaal in Actors' Classic Counterparts

Mark Harmon

as Jake Gyllenhaal in Actors' Classic Counterparts

Tom Cruise

as Jake Gyllenhaal in Actors' Classic Counterparts

Nicolas Cage

as Jake Gyllenhaal in Actors' Classic Counterparts

Harry Hamlin

as Jake Gyllenhaal in Actors' Classic Counterparts

Tom Cruise

as Chris Evans in Actors' Classic Counterparts

Mel Gibson

as Chris Evans in Actors' Classic Counterparts