Suggestions by @mariobrosfan201
1,794 suggestions

E.G. Daily
as Bowser Jr in Super Mario Bros Movie (DON'T CAST THE ILLUMANTION CAST)

Ray Walston
as Mario "Jumpman" Mario Sr. in Super Mario Bros Movie (DON'T CAST THE ILLUMANTION CAST)

Billy West
as Mario "Jumpman" Mario Sr. in Super Mario Bros Movie (DON'T CAST THE ILLUMANTION CAST)

Stephen Root
as Wario in Super Mario Bros Movie (DON'T CAST THE ILLUMANTION CAST)
James Arnold Taylor
as Mario in Super Mario Bros Movie (DON'T CAST THE ILLUMANTION CAST)

Gilbert Gottfried
as Waluigi in Super Mario Bros Movie (DON'T CAST THE ILLUMANTION CAST)

Reginald VelJohnson
as Mario "Jumpman" Mario Sr. in Super Mario Bros Movie (DON'T CAST THE ILLUMANTION CAST)

Jack McBrayer
as Luigi in Super Mario Bros Movie (DON'T CAST THE ILLUMANTION CAST)

Paul Reubens
as Luigi in Super Mario Bros Movie (DON'T CAST THE ILLUMANTION CAST)

Joe Manganiello
as Mario in Super Mario Bros Movie (DON'T CAST THE ILLUMANTION CAST)

Scarlett Johansson
as Wanda in Fairly Loud OddParents House!

Jerry Seinfeld
as Cosmo in Fairly Loud OddParents House!

Keith Scott
as Luigi in The Super Mario Bros Super Show: Reboot!

Jack McBrayer
as Luigi in Super Smash Bros. Ultimate

Matthew Perry
as Mario in Super Smash Bros. Ultimate

Annaka Fourneret
as Waria in Super Mario-Genderswap

Lexi DiBenedetto
as Bowseen in Super Mario-Genderswap

Sophia Woodward
as Maria in Super Mario-Genderswap

Catherine Ashmore Bradley
as Luigia in Super Mario-Genderswap

Charlie Day
as Fix-It Felix Jr. in Wreck It Ralph Live Action