Suggestions by @marian
3,919 suggestions
Michelle Pfeiffer
as Ellen Harvelle in Supernatural.
Teresa Palmer
as Jo Harvelle in Supernatural.
Gary Oldman
as John Winchester in Supernatural.
Robert Carlyle
as John Winchester in Supernatural.
Sean Bean
as John Winchester in Supernatural.
Charles Dance
as John Winchester in Supernatural.
Giles Matthey
as Sam Winchester in Supernatural.
Colin Morgan
as Sam Winchester in Supernatural.
Nathaniel Buzolic
as Sam Winchester in Supernatural.
Bradley James
as Dean Winchester in Supernatural.
Joseph Morgan
as Dean Winchester in Supernatural.
Phoebe Tonkin
as Ruby in Supernatural.
Claire Holt
as Lilith in Supernatural.
David Tennant
as Crowley in Supernatural.
Crispin Glover
as Gabriel. in Supernatural.
Robert Carlyle
as John Winchester in Supernatural
Daniel Sharman
as Dean Winchester in Supernatural
Giles Matthey
as Sam Winchester in Supernatural
Crispin Glover
as John Winchester in Supernatural
Gary Oldman
as John Winchester in Supernatural