Suggestions by @maddddieee

Danielle Campbell

as Ashton in One Of Us Is Lying

Willa Holland

as Ashton in One Of Us Is Lying

Margot Robbie

as Ashton in One Of Us Is Lying

Blake Lively

as Ashton in One Of Us Is Lying

Elizabeth Lail

as Ashton in One Of Us Is Lying

Chloë Grace Moretz

as Ashton in One Of Us Is Lying

Madison Pettis

as Bronwyn in One Of Us Is Lying

Natalie Alyn Lind

as Addy in One Of Us Is Lying

Elle Fanning

as Addy in One Of Us Is Lying

Marlhy Murphy

as Addy in One Of Us Is Lying

Maddie Ziegler

as Addy in One Of Us Is Lying

Kalani Hilliker

as Addy in One Of Us Is Lying

Meg Donnelly

as Addy in One Of Us Is Lying

Peyton Meyer

as Cooper in One Of Us Is Lying

Harris Dickinson

as Cooper in One Of Us Is Lying

Ansel Elgort

as Cooper in One Of Us Is Lying

Rowan Blanchard

as Janae in One Of Us Is Lying

Antonia Fotaras

as Janae in One Of Us Is Lying

Odeya Rush

as Vanessa in One Of Us Is Lying

Sydney Sweeney

as Vanessa in One Of Us Is Lying