Suggestions by @lukejamesbennett

Crash Bandicoot (Character)

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

Sinbad the Sailor

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

Pawbert Lynxley

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

Huntsman

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

Hercules (Disney Character)

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

Captain Phoebus

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

John Smith

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

Simba (The Lion King)

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

The Beast (Prince Adam)

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

Mac (Clifford the Big Red Dog)

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

Ling (Mulan)

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

Espio the Chameleon

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

James the Red Engine

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

E. Aster Bunnymund

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

Valiente (Ferdinand)

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

Ranger (Free Birds)

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

Diego (Ice Age)

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

Stabbington Brothers

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

Brutus "Sideburns" Stabbington

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played

Optimus Prime

as Elmo Lincoln in Characters golden age stars could have played