Suggestions by @lorog

Simon Pegg

as Dr. Thaddeus Sivana in Shazam!: The Next Champion

Jack Black

as Mister Mind in Shazam!: The Next Champion

Idris Elba

as Black Adam in Shazam!: The Next Champion

Jacob Elordi

as Shazam in Shazam!: The Next Champion

Jason Segel

as Shazam in Shazam!: The Next Champion

Guy Pearce

as Two-Face in Batman: Year Three (2006)

Spoiler

as Two-Face in Batman: Year Three (2006)

Olivia Wilde

as Dr. Chase Meridian in Batman: Year Three (2006)

Matthew McConaughey

as Dr. Jonathan Crane in Batman: Year Three (2006)

Will Smith

as Aaron Cash in Batman: Year Three (2006)

Rachel McAdams

as Dr. Harleen Quinzel in Batman: Year Three (2006)

Penélope Cruz

as Talia al Ghul in Batman: Year Three (2006)

Shaun Toub

as Ra's al Ghul in Batman: Year Three (2006)

Jack Nicholson

as The Penguin in Batman: Year Three (2006)

Willem Dafoe

as The Riddler in Batman: Year Three (2006)

Christian Bale

as The Joker in Batman: Year Three (2006)

Bryce Dallas Howard

as Barbara Gordon in Batman: Year Three (2006)

Diane Kruger

as Vicki Vale in Batman: Year Three (2006)

Guy Pearce

as District Attorney Dent in Batman: Year Three (2006)

Talisa Soto

as Catwoman in Batman: Year Three (2006)