Suggestions by @lieutinant_whoareyou

Joe Pesci

as Oswald Cobblepot (Kapelput) in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Zooey Deschanel

as Dr Harleen Quinzel in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Emma Roberts

as Dr Harleen Quinzel in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Kevin Spacey

as Mr. Bloom in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Jason Isaacs

as Blight in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Clancy Brown

as Lyle Bolton in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Marsha, Queen of Diamonds in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Kiefer Sutherland

as Master of the court owls in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Jensen Ackles

as Thomas Wayne Jr. in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Neil McDonough

as Floyd Lawton in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Howie Mandel

as Victor Zsaas in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Andy Serkis

as Dr. Robert Kirkland "Kirk" Langstrom in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Asia Argento

as Talia Al Ghul in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Asia Argento

as Nyssa Al Ghul in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Melissa Barrera

as Talia Al Ghul in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Mikey Madison

as Alexis Kaye in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Hailee Steinfeld

as Alexis Kaye in Batman's Rogues Gallery

Tom Kenny

as The penguin in Batman: the new animated series season one/ episode three: curiosity of the cat

Jennifer Hale

as Catwoman in Batman: the new animated series season one/ episode three: curiosity of the cat

Josh Keaton

as Red Robin in Batman: An Animated Series