Suggestions by @krmickey97
37,430 suggestions
Thomas Haden Church
as John Stifler in American Pie (1999-2012)
John Corbett
as John Stifler in American Pie (1999-2012)
Cary Elwes
as John Stifler in American Pie (1999-2012)
Stephen Dorff
as Nikola in American Pie (1999-2012)
Matthew Lillard
as Nikola in American Pie (1999-2012)
Jared Leto
as Nikola in American Pie (1999-2012)
Lea Salonga
as Joan in American Pie (1999-2012)
Aaron Paul
as Jesse in American Pie (1999-2012)
Devon Sawa
as Harper in American Pie (1999-2012)
James Van Der Beek
as Harper in American Pie (1999-2012)
Elden Henson
as Jesse in American Pie (1999-2012)
Ethan Embry
as Jesse in American Pie (1999-2012)
Ryan Reynolds
as Vincent "Vince" Latham in American Pie (1999-2012)
Ryan Phillippe
as Vincent "Vince" Latham in American Pie (1999-2012)
Kip Pardue
as Vincent "Vince" Latham in American Pie (1999-2012)
Eugene Byrd
as Michael Flaherty in American Pie (1999-2012)
Will Friedle
as Michael Flaherty in American Pie (1999-2012)
Giovanni Ribisi
as Michael Flaherty in American Pie (1999-2012)
Seth Green
as Michael Flaherty in American Pie (1999-2012)
Sara Rue
as Justine in American Pie (1999-2012)