Suggestions by @kristinwalters

Melanie Lynskey

as Patricia Campbell in The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires

Selma Blair

as Grace Cavanaugh in The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires

Melissa McCarthy

as Kitty Scruggs in The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires

Christina Milian

as Wilma Anson in The House Across The Lake

Jensen Ackles

as Boone in The House Across The Lake

Amy Acker

as Casey in The House Across The Lake

Tatiana Maslany

as Nora in The Midnight Library

Ella Purnell

as April in The Rules of Magic

Sarah Jeffery

as Bronwyn Rojas in One of Us is Next

Zoe Margaret Coletti

as Maeve Rojas in One of Us is Next

Matthew Gray Gubler

as Eli Kleinfield in One Of Us Is Lying

Zoe Colletti

as Maeve in One Of Us Is Lying

Timothée Chalamet

as Vincent Owens in The Rules of Magic