Suggestions by @kikideetz

Faye Dunaway

as Gale Weathers in Scream (1980)

Harrison Ford

as Dewey Riley in Scream (1980)

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Sidney Prescott in Scream (1980)

Jamie Foxx

as Deputy Perkins in Scream 4 (2001)

Luke Perry

as Detective Hoss in Scream 4 (2001)

Sandra Bullock

as Deputy Judy Hicks in Scream 4 (2001)

Calista Flockhart

as Rebecca Walters in Scream 4 (2001)

Chris Evans

as Robbie Mercer in Scream 4 (2001)

Meg Ryan

as Chloe Patterson in Scream 4 (2001)

Julianne Moore

as Rachel Barnes in Scream 4 (2001)

Shiri Appleby

as Trudie Harold in Scream 4 (2001)

Tobey Maguire

as Charlie Walker in Scream 4 (2001)

A. J. Cook

as Sherrie Marconi in Scream 4 (2001)

Alexis Bledel

as Marnie Cooper in Scream 4 (2001)

Katie Holmes

as Jenny Randall in Scream 4 (2001)

Paul Walker

as Trevor Sheldon in Scream 4 (2001)

Melissa Sagemiller

as Olivia Morris in Scream 4 (2001)

Meryl Streep

as Kate Roberts in Scream 4 (2001)

Christina Ricci

as Kirby Reed in Scream 4 (2001)

Kirsten Dunst

as Jill Roberts in Scream 4 (2001)