Suggestions by @josiahabner1
673 suggestions
Sebastian Arcelus
as John Wilkies Booth in Assassins
J.K. Simmons
as Priest Jeffrey Miller in Siren Head

MatPat
as Jax in Amazing Digital Circus

Noel Fisher
as Jax in Amazing Digital Circus

Marc Maron
as Jax in Amazing Digital Circus
J.K. Simmons
as Caine in Amazing Digital Circus

Bobby Cannavale
as Captain Bruce Columbus in Siren Head

Bob Odenkirk
as Captain Bruce Columbus in Siren Head

Charlotte Hope
as Ranger Isabella Miller in Siren Head

Addison Timlin
as Ranger Isabella Miller in Siren Head
Gary Busey
as Wolfgang Wildbreaker in Siren Head
Michael Berryman
as Wolfgang Wildbreaker in Siren Head

Steve Buscemi
as Wolfgang Wildbreaker in Siren Head
David Harbour
as Wolfgang Wildbreaker in Siren Head

Joaquin Phoenix
as Wolfgang Wildbreaker in Siren Head

Will Arnett
as Captain Bruce Columbus in Siren Head

Tony Shalhoub
as Priest Jeffrey Miller in Siren Head

Lance Barber
as Priest Jeffrey Miller in Siren Head
Hugh Grant
as Priest Jeffrey Miller in Siren Head

Alfred Molina
as Priest Jeffrey Miller in Siren Head