Suggestions by @jigglyjai

Buzz Lightyear (Toy Story)

as Mostly Good in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Clancy Wiggum

as Bad Apple in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

The Annoying Orange

as Neutral in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Jeffy

as Neutral in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Brooklyn T. Guy

as Neutral in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Kenny McCormick

as Fairly Good in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Stan Marsh

as Fairly Good in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Kyle Broflovski

as Fairly Good in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Mimi (Canimals)

as Bad Apple in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Jigglypuff

as Neutral in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Niffty

as Neutral in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Buttercup (The Powerpuff Girls)

as Fairly Good in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Applejack

as Mostly Good in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Cozy Glow

as Evil Villain in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Uka Uka

as Devil Incarnate in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Emperor Sheev Palpatine (Darth Sidious)

as Devil Incarnate in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Anakin Skywalker (Darth Vader)

as Evil Villain in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Rarity

as Fairly Good in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Charlie Bucket

as Pure Angel in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)

Twilight Sparkle

as Mostly Good in Fictional Characters Arranged By The Moral Scale (Good to Evil)