Suggestions by @jdfitzgerald
6,173 suggestions
John Oliver
as James in James to the Rescue
John Oliver
as James the Red Engine (if 100% Male) in Thomas & Friends (21st Century)
Alan Cumming
as Duncan in Island of Sodor
Nigel Planer
as Fearless Freddie in Island of Sodor
Ian McKellen
as Duke in Island of Sodor
Chris and Liam Hemsworth
as Mighty Mac in Island of Sodor
Ben Whishaw
as Rusty in Island of Sodor
Rhys Ifans
as Peter Sam in Island of Sodor
Craig Ferguson
as Sir Handel in Island of Sodor
Rob Brydon
as Rheneas in Island of Sodor
Timothy Dalton
as Skarloey in Island of Sodor
Lily James
as Lady the magical engine in Island of Sodor
Dove Cameron
as Rosie the pink engine in Island of Sodor
Tara Strong
as Mavis in Celebrities as Thomas the Tank Engine Characters
Ortis Deley
as Toad the brake van in Island of Sodor
Alan Marriott
as Trevor the traction engine in Island of Sodor
Kylie Minogue
as Caroline the car in Island of Sodor
Blake Clark
as Terence the tractor in Island of Sodor
Richard Osman
as Harold the helicopter in Island of Sodor
Deobia Oparei
as Hector in Island of Sodor