Suggestions by @jdeav

Christopher McCulloch

as Mayor Fredbear in MTS Hearts

Erika Henningsen

as Mangle in MTS Hearts

Ryan Reynolds

as Foxy The Pirate Fox in MTS Hearts

Zendaya

as Chica The Chicken in MTS Hearts

Tom Holland

as Bonnie The Bunny in MTS Hearts

Mark Fischbach

as Freddy Fazbear in MTS Hearts

Clark Gregg

as Agent Phil Coulson in MTS Hearts

Colbie Smulders

as Maria Hill in MTS Hearts

Samuel L. Jackson

as Nick Fury in MTS Hearts

Patrick Stewart

as Professor Charles Xavier in MTS Hearts

J.K. Simmons

as J. Jonah Jameson in MTS Hearts

Laura Bailey

as Natasha Romanoff/Black Widow in MTS Hearts

Chris Hemsworth

as Thor Odinson in MTS Hearts

Chris Evans

as Steve Rogers/Captain America in MTS Hearts

Robert Downey Jr.

as Tony Stark/Iron Man in MTS Hearts

Fred Tatasciore

as Bruce Banner/Hulk in MTS Hearts

Steve Blum

as Logan Howlett/Wolverine in MTS Hearts

Josh Keaton

as Peter Parker/Spider-Man in MTS Hearts

Dee Bradley Baker

as Fred (the "My Leg!" guy) in MTS Hearts

Jill Talley

as Karen Plankton in MTS Hearts