Suggestions by @jasonyoung

Rutger Hauer

as Kaecilius in Doctor Strange (1996)

Mako

as Ancient One in Doctor Strange (1996)

Giancarlo Esposito

as Karl Mordo in Doctor Strange (1996)

Meg Ryan

as Christine Palmer in Doctor Strange (1996)

Donnie Yen

as Wong in Doctor Strange (1996)

Daniel Day-Lewis

as Stephen Strange in Doctor Strange (1996)

Andrew Lincoln

as Nick Fury in Thor (2011)

Bradley Cooper

as Clint Barton in Thor (2011)

Bob Odenkirk

as Phil Coulson in Thor (2011)

Jeffrey Wright

as Jasper Sitwell in Thor (2011)

Richard E. Grant

as Laufey in Thor (2011)

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Frigga in Thor (2011)

Pierce Brosnan

as Odin in Thor (2011)

Kristofer Hivju

as Volstagg in Thor (2011)

Brian Tee

as Hogun in Thor (2011)

Billy Magnussen

as Fandral in Thor (2011)

Gal Gadot

as Sif in Thor (2011)

Geoffrey Rush

as Erik Selvig in Thor (2011)

Aubrey Plaza

as Darcy Lewis in Thor (2011)

Anne Hathaway

as Jane Foster in Thor (2011)