Suggestions by @jasleenfaydelarosa

Miss Collins

as Mrs. Sharon Norbury in Mean Girls (if horror movie characters made it)

Nancy Downs

as Janis Ian in Mean Girls (if horror movie characters made it)

Chris Hargensen

as Regina George in Mean Girls (if horror movie characters made it)

Dale (Lisa Frankenstein)

as Lisa Frankenstein in Fictional Characters Sorted by Horror Movies

Janet (Lisa Frankenstein)

as Lisa Frankenstein in Fictional Characters Sorted by Horror Movies

Jane Delano

as Chelsea Briggs in Beacon Street Girls (if horror movie characters made it)

Makani Young

as Katani Summers in Beacon Street Girls (if horror movie characters made it)

Neve Campbell

as Lazy Linda in Horrid Henry (90s Teen Cast)

Brigg (My Super Psycho Swee 16)

as Logan Bruno in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)

Blair Underwood

as Izaak in The Idol (80s)

Taffy (Lisa Frankenstein)

as Claudia Kishi in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)

Pam Miller

as Shannon Kilbourne in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)

Winnie Carruthers

as Dawn Schafer in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)

Sadie Harper

as Abby Stevenson in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)

Makani Young

as Jessi Ramsey in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)

C. Berman/Ziggy Berman

as Mallory Pike in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)

Lisa Swallows

as Stacey McGill in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)

Skye Rotter

as Mary Anne Spier in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)

Sienna Shaw

as Kristy Thomas in The Babysitters Club (if horror movie characters made it)

Kelly Hu

as Dyanne in The Idol (80s)