Suggestions by @jasleenfaydelarosa

James Dean

as John Bender in The Breakfast Club (1955)

Vanessa Palmer

as Debbie Reynolds in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Hope Lange

as Laura Lee in Yellowjackets (50s)

Debbie Reynolds

as Young Vanessa Palmer in Yellowjackets (50s)

Lucille Ball

as Vanessa Palmer in Yellowjackets (50s)

Nancy Kilgas

as Young Misty Quigley in Yellowjackets (50s)

Diahann Carroll

as Young Taissa Turner in Yellowjackets (50s)

Barboura Morris

as Young Shauna Shipman in Yellowjackets (50s)

Roger Corman

as Director in Jennifer (1958)

Nancy Kilgas

as Valerie Hartman in '80s Actors in the '50s

Taissa Turner

as Diahann Carroll in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Misty Quigley

as Nancy Kilgas in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Nancy Kilgas

as Norma Watson in Carrie (1956)

Shauna Shipman

as Barboura Morris in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Nancy (Jennifer 1978)

as Nancy Kilgas in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Chloe (My Super Psycho Sweet 16)

as Nancy Kilgas in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Ally Burgess

as Nancy Kilgas in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Susanne Sidney

as Mary Blake in Carrie (1956)

Margot Kidder

as Linda Martin in High School Hellcats (1988)

John Hughes

as Director in High School Hellcats (1988)