Suggestions by @japemanx
84 suggestions

Jaden Smith
as Pietro McGillacuddy in Left Handed Slugger
Barack Obama
as Peck McGillacuddy in Left Handed Slugger
Michael McKean
as Police Captain Roger Morgan-Hinder in Left Handed Slugger

Rico Rodriguez
as Clark Benedetto in Left Handed Slugger

Eugene Mirman
as Vice President Borrigan Backo in Left Handed Slugger
Evgeniya Gromova
as First Lady Kalinda Brosnan in Left Handed Slugger

Doug E. Doug
as President Doug Brosnan in Left Handed Slugger

Ayo Edebiri
as Rhonda Lore in Left Handed Slugger
Griffin Newman
as Speed Goman in Left Handed Slugger

Chloe Fineman
as Chloe Markowitz in Left Handed Slugger

Alex Ross Perry
as Seth Jabonowitz in Left Handed Slugger
Jon Gabrus
as Casey Leech in Left Handed Slugger
Nish Kumar
as Brock Romesh in Left Handed Slugger

Kensington Tallman
as Gundun Cork in Left Handed Slugger
Miles Wei
as Jon Peters in Idiosyncratic Imbeciles

Jeffrey Wright
as Rothchild "Ripper" MacNee in Idiosyncratic Imbeciles
Jon Gabrus
as Robert Evans in Idiosyncratic Imbeciles

Iman Vellani
as Gaspara Rex in Idiosyncratic Imbeciles
Nish Kumar
as "Pa" Dohinder Dorkas in Idiosyncratic Imbeciles

Dennis Boutsikaris
as Mitch Effery in Idiosyncratic Imbeciles