Suggestions by @jameseller
1,851 suggestions

Ben-Hur (1959)
as Best Picture 1960 in Oscars Do-over

Billy Wilder
as Best Director 1960 in Oscars Do-over

Charlton Heston
as Best Actor 1960 in Oscars Do-over
Doris Day
as Best Actress 1960 in Oscars Do-over

Arthur O'Connell
as Best Supporting Actor 1960 in Oscars Do-over

Thelma Ritter
as Best Supporting Actress 1960 in Oscars Do-over

The Magnificent Seven (1960)
as Best Picture 1961 in Oscars Do-over

John Sturges
as Best Director 1961 in Oscars Do-over

Yul Brynner
as Best Actor 1961 in Oscars Do-over

Deborah Kerr
as Best Actress 1961 in Oscars Do-over
Charles Bronson
as Best Supporting Actor 1961 in Oscars Do-over

Shirley Knight
as Best Supporting Actress 1961 in Oscars Do-over

West Side Story
as Best Picture 1962 in Oscars Do-over

Stanley Kramer
as Best Director 1962 in Oscars Do-over
Maximilian Schell
as Best Actor 1962 in Oscars Do-over

Audrey Hepburn
as Best Actress 1962 in Oscars Do-over

George Chakiris
as Best Supporting Actor 1962 in Oscars Do-over
Rita Moreno
as Best Supporting Actress 1962 in Oscars Do-over

To Kill A Mockingbird
as Best Picture 1963 in Oscars Do-over
Arthur Penn
as Best Director 1963 in Oscars Do-over