Suggestions by @jameseller
1,815 suggestions

Olivia de Havilland
as Best Actress 1942 in Oscars Do-over
James Gleason
as Best Supporting Actor 1942 in Oscars Do-over
Teresa Wright
as Best Supporting Actress 1942 in Oscars Do-over

Yankee Doodle Dandy
as Best Picture 1943 in Oscars Do-over
Sam Wood
as Best Director 1943 in Oscars Do-over

James Cagney
as Best Actor 1943 in Oscars Do-over
Katharine Hepburn
as Best Actress 1943 in Oscars Do-over
Walter Huston
as Best Supporting Actor 1943 in Oscars Do-over
Susan Peters
as Best Supporting Actress 1943 in Oscars Do-over

Casablanca (film)
as Best Picture 1944 in Oscars Do-over
Henry King
as Best Director 1944 in Oscars Do-over

Mickey Rooney
as Best Actor 1944 in Oscars Do-over
Joan Fontaine
as Best Actress 1944 in Oscars Do-over
Charles Coburn
as Best Supporting Actor 1944 in Oscars Do-over
Paulette Goddard
as Best Supporting Actress 1944 in Oscars Do-over
Otto Preminger
as Best Director 1945 in Oscars Do-over

Cary Grant
as Best Actor 1945 in Oscars Do-over

Bette Davis
as Best Actress 1945 in Oscars Do-over

Barry Fitzgerald
as Best Supporting Actor 1945 in Oscars Do-over

Jennifer Jones
as Best Supporting Actress 1945 in Oscars Do-over