Suggestions by @jackstrauss
9 suggestions
John Williams
as Composer in E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial
+3-0Score: +3
J.K. Simmons
as Mayor Larry Vaughn in Jaws
+5-2Score: +3

John C. Reilly
as Hendricks in Jaws
+2-0Score: +2
John Williams
as Composer in Jaws
+8-1Score: +7

Johnny Galecki
as Matt Hooper in Jaws
+7-4Score: +3

David Dastmalchian
as Romero in Escape from New York
+1-1Score: 0
Jack Black
as Cabbie in Escape from New York
+2-0Score: +2
J.K. Simmons
as Bob Hauk in Escape from New York
+3-0Score: +3

Winston Duke
as Duke of New York in Escape from New York
+4-1Score: +3