Suggestions by @jackslater4
1,838 suggestions

Leo McKern
as Mycroft Holmes in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes
Max von Sydow
as Ernst Stavro Blofeld in Multiple Actors Playing the Same Characters

Christopher Lambert
as Tarzan/John Clayton/Viscount Greystoke in Multiple Actors Playing the Same Characters

Nicol Williamson
as Sherlock Holmes in Multiple Actors Playing the Same Characters

Laurence Olivier
as 1960s Gandalf in Actors who could have played Gandalf in various decades.

John Gielgud
as 1960s Gandalf in Actors who could have played Gandalf in various decades.
Ralph Richardson
as 1960s Gandalf in Actors who could have played Gandalf in various decades.

Ralph Richardson
as Professor Albus Dumbledore in Harry Potter (Perfect Casting)

Mel Brooks
as Mel in Celebrities With The Same Name

Richard Armitage
as Richard in Celebrities With The Same Name

Richard Burton
as Richard in Celebrities With The Same Name

Walton Goggins
as Three-fingered Jack in The Mask of Zorro (2025)

Franco Nero
as as 2nd Lt. Jean-Claude Clermont in The Monuments Men (1984)

Yul Brynner
as Russia in Best Actors/Actresses by Country

Harrison Ford
as Martin Pawley in The Searchers (1976)

Christopher Lee
as William Tavington in The Patriot (1980)

Jenny Agutter
as Heather McLeod in Highlander (1976)

John Goodman
as Paul Bunyan in Tall Tale (1995)

Trevor Howard
as Charles Cornwallis, 2nd Earl Cornwallis in The Patriot (1980)

Robert Ryan
as Col. Chester Phillips in Captain America: The First Avenger {1971}