Suggestions by @j_bkr

Tim Roth

as Victor Zsasz in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Jeffrey Tambor

as Quincy Sharp in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Amanda Peet

as Penelope Young in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Danny Trejo

as Bane in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Laurence Fishburne

as Aaron Cash in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Brad Dourif

as Jonathan Crane in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Tom Selleck

as James Gordon in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Bruce Campbell

as Edward Nygma in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Michael Clarke Duncan

as Waylon Jones in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Julia Stiles

as Barbara Gordon in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Cameron Diaz

as Harleen Quinzel in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Sharon Stone

as Pamela Isley in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Willem Dafoe

as Joker in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Jim Caviezel

as Bruce Wayne in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Damon Wayans Jr.

as Matt in Until Dawn (2005)

Shawn Ashmore

as Josh in Until Dawn (2005)

Elisha Cuthbert

as Jessica in Until Dawn (2005)

Mila Kunis

as Emily in Until Dawn (2005)

Amanda Seyfried

as Ashley in Until Dawn (2005)

Paul Dano

as Chris in Until Dawn (2005)