Suggestions by @itsgrapes_exe
548 suggestions
William Parry
as Captain Edward Smith in Actors by Historical Figures They've Played
Benjamin Rayson
as Charlemagne in Actors by Historical Figures They've Played
Antonio Cipriano
as Racetrack Higgins in Newsies
Alexander Gemignani
as Jean Valjean in Les Mis: The Dream Cast
Anthony Perkins
as Davey Jacobs in Newsies (Vintage Movie Musical)
Christian Borle
as Billy Flynn in Chicago Live
Andrew Rannells
as Leo Bloom in The Producers: Live!
Josh Gad
as Max Bialystock in The Producers: Live!
Leonard Frey
as Elmer in Newsies (Vintage Movie Musical)
David Winters
as Romeo in Newsies (Vintage Movie Musical)
Tucker Smith
as Finch Cortez in Newsies (Vintage Movie Musical)
George Chakiris
as Specs in Newsies (Vintage Movie Musical)
Kelli O'Hara
as Sarah in Company (Musical)
Annaleigh Ashford
as Susan in Company (Musical)
Stephen Bogardus
as Rabbi (Present) in Harmony: A New Musical
Nathan Salstone
as Rabbi (Past) in Harmony: A New Musical
Ben Fankhauser
as Gordon in A New Brain
Betsy Wolfe
as Beth Shepard in Merrily We Roll Along
Tracie Thoms
as Gussie Carnegie in Merrily We Roll Along
Stephanie J. Block
as Mary Flynn in Merrily We Roll Along