Suggestions by @itsgrapes_exe
578 suggestions
Jordan Fisher
as Bobby Strong in Urinetown
Daveed Diggs
as Mr. Cladwell in Urinetown
Laura Benanti
as Penelope Pennywise in Urinetown
Bonnie Milligan
as Paulette Buonofante in Legally Blonde (Revival)
Anne Hathaway
as Mary Rodgers in Stephen Sondheim Biopic
Colin Jost
as John F. Kennedy in Presidents Biopic
Christian Borle
as Tim Curry in Biopics
Jonathan Groff
as John Hinckley Jr. in Assassins
Krystal Joy Brown
as Tabitha/Cheshire Cat/Caterpillar 2 in Alice By Heart
Jack Wolfe
as Alfred/White Rabbit in Alice By Heart
Brian d'Arcy James
as Dr. Butridge/King of Hearts in Alice By Heart
Lizzy McAlpine
as Alice in Alice By Heart
Sutton Foster
as Nurse/Queen of Hearts in Alice By Heart
Samantha Pauly
as Clarissa/Queen of Diamonds in Alice By Heart
Cole Escola
as Dodgy/Duchess in Alice By Heart
Christian Borle
as Harold/Mad Hatter in Alice By Heart
Sky Lakota-Lynch
as Nigel/Dormouse in Alice By Heart
Jordan Fisher
as Angus/Caterpillar in Alice By Heart
Katya Zamolodchikova
as Duchess in Alice by Heart
Eva Noblezada
as Natalie Goodman in Next to Normal