Suggestions by @heemhsn

Noma Dumezweni

as Lottie Johnson in Survivor

Dianna Agron

as Sarah Thompson in Survivor

Stephen Lang

as Nate Parker in Survivor

Isabela Merced

as Maya Rodriguez in Survivor

Luke Bracey

as Darren Blake in Survivor

Dale Dickey

as Bethany Parker in Survivor

Rosario Dawson

as Queen Amaya in Disney Princesses

Jaime Camil

as King Magnifico in Disney Princesses

Idris Elba

as Triton in Disney Princesses

Laura Kariuki

as Tiana in Disney Princesses

Dua Lipa

as Megara in Disney Princesses

Nicholas Galitzine

as Ty Carson in The Texas Chainsaw Massacre

Selena Gomez

as Chasity Honrada in Survivor

Nicholas Galitzine

as Henry Dieu-le-Veut in Sea of Thieves

Karl Urban

as Edward Teach in Sea of Thieves

Samara Weaving

as Elsa Redd in Sea of Thieves

Milly Alcock

as Gwen Stacey in Spider-Man: Freshman Year

Anya Chalotra

as Circe in DCEU Fancasting

Dan Amboyer

as Hal Jordan in DCEU Fancasting

Avantika

as Rachel Roth in DCEU Fancasting