Suggestions by @gordillio

Logan Lerman

as Hal Jordan (Green Lantern) in All Superheroes and Villains (DC, Marvel, & Dark Horse Comics)

Antony Starr

as Logan (Wolverine) in All Superheroes and Villains (DC, Marvel, & Dark Horse Comics)

Matthew Goode

as Eobard Thawne (Reverse Flash) in All Superheroes and Villains (DC, Marvel, & Dark Horse Comics)

Dominic Purcell

as Juggernaut in X-Men MCU

LaMonica Garrett

as Bishop in X-Men MCU

Ethan Hawke

as James Gordon in DCEU Rebooted

Kevin Costner

as James Gordon in DCEU Rebooted

Edgar Ramírez

as Bane in Batman Universe

Dan Stevens

as Scarecrow in Batman Universe

Timothy Olyphant

as Slade Wilson (Deathstroke) in All Superheroes and Villains (DC, Marvel, & Dark Horse Comics)

Clive Standen

as Ben Grimm (Thing) in All Superheroes and Villains (DC, Marvel, & Dark Horse Comics)

Keanu Reeves

as John Constantine in All Superheroes and Villains (DC, Marvel, & Dark Horse Comics)

Charlie Cox

as John Constantine in All Superheroes and Villains (DC, Marvel, & Dark Horse Comics)

Chiwetel Ejiofor

as John Stewart (Green Lantern) in All Superheroes and Villains (DC, Marvel, & Dark Horse Comics)

Clive Standen

as Ben Grimm in Marvel Cinematic Universe

Clémence Poésy

as Sue Storm in Marvel Cinematic Universe

Colin Farrell

as Reed Richards in Marvel Cinematic Universe

Jared Leto

as Norrin Radd in Marvel Cinematic Universe

Léa Seydoux

as Raven Darkhölme (Mystique) in All Superheroes and Villains (DC, Marvel, & Dark Horse Comics)

Tom Hopper

as Warren Worthington III in MCU X-Men