Suggestions by @girlhelp

Cleavon Little

as Detective Tapp in Saw (2004)

Don Cheadle

as Detective Tapp in Saw (2004)

Jamie Foxx

as Detective Tapp in Saw (2004)

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Lawrence Gordon in Saw (2004)

Edward Norton

as Adam Faulkner-Stanheight in Saw (2004)

Tobin Bell

as Jigsaw in Saw (2004)

Leonardo DiCaprio

as F**kin' Lou in Fight Club '24

Ana de Armas

as Marla Singer in Fight Club '24

Leigh Whannell

as The Narrator in Fight Club '24

Rita Moreno

as Beulah Davis in Come From Away

Vanessa Hudgens

as Janice in Come From Away

Kara Lindsay

as Janice in Come From Away

Kimiko Glenn

as Janice in Come From Away

Fred Armisen

as Geraldo, a shifty barkeep in the Republic of Pirates in Our Flag Means Death (1992)

Andrew Rannells

as Lucius, a scribe on the Revenge tasked with keeping a record in Our Flag Means Death (1992)

Christian Borle

as Edward Teach aka Blackbeard the legendary pirate captain. in Our Flag Means Death (1992)

Ariana DeBose

as Bonifacia Jimenez/Jim, a skilled fighter in Our Flag Means Death (1992)

Colin O'Donoghue

as William Shakespeare in Something Rotten!