Suggestions by @gillianreinhart

Paget Brewster

as Dean Lionetti in First Down

Diana Silvers

as Violet in Fourth Wing

Claudia Doumit

as Sabrina Allali in Icebreaker

Chad Connell

as Drew in They never learn

Timothée Chalamet

as Jasper in They never learn

Matthew Daddario

as Bash in They never learn

Alex Fitzalan

as Wes in They never learn

Shemar Moore

as Detective Flynn in They never learn

Paget Brewster

as Detective Abbott in They never learn

Yara Shahidi

as Mikayla in They never learn

Salma Hayek

as Mina in They never learn

Rudy Pankow

as Alex in They never learn

Josh Lucas

as Kinnear in They never learn

Alba Baptista

as Carly in They never learn

Sandra Oh

as Sandra in They never learn

Mia Healey

as Allison in They never learn

Anne Hathaway

as Aunt Natalie in I Think I Love You

Sandra Bullock

as Emma’s Mom in I Think I Love You

Simu Liu

as Emma’s Dad in I Think I Love You

Jabari Banks

as Matt in I Think I Love You