Suggestions by @germanacola

Jeff (Mirror, Mirror)

as 1990s in Big Men on Campus by Decade

Nikki Chandler

as Carly Simmons in Flying (if horror movie characters made it)

Brigg (My Super Psycho Swee 16)

as Mark Sanderson in Flying (if horror movie characters made it)

Skye Rotter

as Robin Crew in Flying (if horror movie characters made it)

Madison Penrose (My Super Psycho Sweet 16)

as Leah Kilbourne in Flying (if horror movie characters made it)

Derek (My Super Psycho Sweet 16)

as Tommy Warnecki in Flying (if horror movie characters made it)

Kim (Mirror, Mirror)

as Stacy in Flying (if horror movie characters made it)

Megan Gordon

as Robin Crew in Flying (if horror movie characters made it)

Charleen Kane

as Leah Kilbourne in Flying (if horror movie characters made it)

Brick Bazooka

as Slasher Smile in Sort by Tropes

Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers

as Melissa Joan Hart in If this Actor starred in...

Charlotte Watsford

as Purple in Fictional Characters by Colours of the Rainbow

Cleo Sertori

as Orange in Fictional Characters by Colours of the Rainbow

Astrid Deetz

as Athena/Minerva in Fictional Characters by Camp Half-Blood Sorting

Kim (Mirror, Mirror)

as Aphrodite/Venus in Fictional Characters by Camp Half-Blood Sorting

Charleen Kane

as Aphrodite/Venus in Fictional Characters by Camp Half-Blood Sorting

Gwendy Doll

as Hades/Pluto in Fictional Characters by Camp Half-Blood Sorting

Cinderella (Disney Character)

as District 8 in Sorting Fictional Characters Into Hunger Games Districts

Nicky (Tea Sisters)

as Amybeth McNulty in Which character would like to see each Actor and Actresses play in Live Action

Nicky (Tea Sisters)

as Sadie Sink in Casting Roles Actors and actresses as Characters Live action